Mamdani disbands police unit targeting terrorism and violent protests, replaces with unarmed unit using “dialogue” and “de-escalation”

November 17, 2026 • 8:00 am

Yep, Mamdani is keeping his campaign promises in a way that is delighting Democratic Socialists, for it amounts to disbanding the police—at least a police unit dedicated to fighting terrorism and violent protests. Hizzoner couches it as a step forward and a fulfillment of his pledge, but what it will amount to is giving license to terrorism and violent protests, whose participants know that the cops won’t be there. What’s worse is that Mamdani’s plan is to stop the protests and terrorism with DIALOGUE and DE-ESCALATION instead of cops.  Yes, maybe that will work on rare occasions but it’s best to have the copes on hand, too.  I am sure that, in light of protests we’ve seen in the last five years, you know how well dialogue and de-escalation will work.

I woke up to find the video below of the Mayor’s announcement, sent by reader Jay, who added, “It took me the longest time to figure out that this wasn’t parody.”  And indeed, the whole thing, including the handshake at the end, shouts “parody.” It’s stiff, overscripted and, to me, scary. But it isn’t parody!!

The NYT and Free Press have different takes on this, of course, with the NYT giving a more neutral take but also adding the approval of the Democratic Socialists of America, of which Mamdani is one, while the Free Press is more op-ed-ish (I agree with their take). Below are excerpts from both sides.

From the NYT (click to read or find the article archived here).

At 6:59 a.m. on Monday, Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a social media video to announce that he was disbanding the Strategic Response Group, a specialized police unit that has been criticized for its handling of protests.

The video was a 102-second victory lap, with Mamdani adopting a mission-accomplished tone for fulfilling a campaign vow.

But then his administration’s messaging got more complicated.

Roughly an hour later, Mr. Mamdani appeared again, this time with his police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, giving a more nuanced presentation to WABC-TV that sought to reassure New Yorkers that the changes would not make New York less safe.

. . . In its cautious approach in announcing the changes, the Mamdani administration seemed to acknowledge the potential volatility of doing anything that revamps Police Department protocol. Indeed, city leaders, police unions and activists were sharply divided over how the changes would affect clashes between officers and demonstrators.

Under the new plan, civilians from the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety would act as the first line of communication with protesters. They would create a dialogue with demonstrators with the goal of de-escalating tension before it can erupt into violence.

I can imagine how effective a group of unarmed officials in civilian clothes will be in “de-escalating tension” like the stuff we saw recently in European demonstrations! “Please, stop the looting and burning. It is hurting your fellow New Yorkers!”  But I digress. More from the NYT:

“This will not be a uniformed police unit,” Mr Mamdani said. “It will be made up of civilians without weapons or arrest powers.”

The civilians would work with 30 officers in a new unit known as the First Amendment Support Team. They will be trained in communication and de-escalation, as well as crowd management.

A new patrol unit of trained officers would make arrests “in rare instances, if necessary,” according to a statement from the mayor’s office. That unit would also take on other responsibilities that once fell to the Strategic Response Group, such as searching for missing people, patrolling major events like the Thanksgiving Day parade and responding to large-scale crime scenes.

“There will be no long guns, tear gas, kettling or pepper spray used as crowd control tactics,” said Chi Ossé, a New York City Council member who appeared in the video with Mr. Mamdani and who previously had introduced legislation known as the CURB Act, which aimed to restrict the Strategic Response Group’s tactics.

. . . In a statement, the Democratic Socialists hailed the mayor’s announcement as a “victory” and “historic.”

“The S.R.G. and its predecessors are violent teams that for decades have suppressed the people’s constitutional right to protest and organize,” the statement said.

. . . .Vincent Vallelong, president of the [police] sergeants’ union, noted in a statement that officers in the group were at Gracie Mansion in March, when, during a protest by right-wing agitators, two men tried to throw homemade bombs into the crowd.

“I fear this approach will embolden violent agitators to infiltrate peaceful demonstrations, putting protesters, police and bystanders at risk,” Sergeant Vallelong said.

. . . . The decision also divided members of the City Council. While Mr. Ossé and other progressive members hailed the changes, Joann Ariola, a councilwoman representing Howard Beach, said the mayor was appeasing his base at the expense of New Yorkers’ safety.

“When bridges are blocked and streets are overrun with agitators,” she wrote on social media, “who is going to keep New Yorkers safe?”

Indeed.  Who? Will discussion and de-escalation stop rioting? When the Democratic Socialists praise something like this, you have to be suspicious, just as you had to be suspicious when a spokesman for the Muslim Brotherhood applauded El-Sayed’s election in Michigan.  And the last question is one echoed by the Free Press article (click if you have a subscription), which is, as expected, quite critical. The author was a federal prosecutor in Brooklyn for a decade. Click below.

An excerpt:

For over a decade, I served as a federal prosecutor in Brooklyn, where I prosecuted terrorists, including ISIS fighters and those who tried to help them. It taught me something most New Yorkers never have to think about: A crowd is an opportunity for people who mean to do harm. I saw firsthand how protests can be infiltrated by criminals and terrorists who use the cover of peaceful demonstrators to carry out violence.

That is why Mayor Mamdani’s decision yesterday to disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG) alarms me.

The SRG is the department’s specialized unit trained and equipped to stop violence and terrorism at protests. The mayor is replacing 500 highly trained uniformed officers with three new de-escalation teams made up of unarmed civilians and backup patrol cops authorized to make arrests at protests only “in rare instances.” The changes will take effect by spring—just as the weather warms and protest season returns.

In a statement announcing the disbandment, the mayor said, “New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat.” To be sure, peaceful protesters deserve respect. But he’s missing the point. Protests are dynamic. They can turn from speech to violence in seconds, and when they do, we need highly trained officers ready to handle it.

We have seen what happens when they are not. The SRG’s predecessor, the Disorder Control Unit, was created after the 1991 Crown Heights riots in Brooklyn, when a state investigation found the NYPD unprepared and ill-equipped as three days of violence tore through the neighborhood. The city learned that lesson the hard way. It should not have to learn it again.

We are trading a tested unit for an untested promise.

Today, the threat of civil unrest is still very real. We have seen protests in this city that have turned violent—smashed windows, burning buses, physical assaults. In 2020, two attorneys threw a Molotov cocktail into an NYPD vehicle during a protest in Brooklyn. In March of this year, two men accused of being ISIS supporters threw homemade bombs at a protest outside Gracie Mansion. And look at what is happening abroad in France: More than half a million people took to the streets, enraged over the cost of living, and parts of the demonstrations descended into arson and looting.

Most protesters are peaceful. But it takes only a few people determined to commit violence, and the city needs a force ready to stop them.

. . .Dialogue teams don’t stand a chance against criminals. Just hours after Mamdani announced he would disband the SRG, two unarmed peace officers were shot while conducting a wellness check in the Bronx. The man who shot them didn’t want to have a dialogue. Neither do terrorists. That leaves the backup patrol cops. They may receive crowd-management training, but they will be hamstrung with new restrictions when facing down criminals who know that resisting arrest and assaulting a cop are no longer prosecuted with seriousness. Moreover, it will be a part-time assignment for officers who spend most of their time on patrol, and it is being stood up from scratch. We are trading a tested unit for an untested promise.

The most immediate effect of the decision to disband the SRG is the message it sends—it emboldens those determined to wreak havoc on our streets. Criminals will be more likely to commit violence knowing that there will be no one there equipped to stop them.

The article discusses the people who will be hurt by this decision, including peaceful protestors who may have agitators embedded in them, religious people like the many Jews who have been attacked in New York or were victims of hate crimes (see below the fold), owners of bodegas and small businesses who get attacked and looted during protests (try discussing looters out of looting!), and commuters and bystanders whose lives are disrupted by non-peaceful protests.  Author Komatireddy ends this way:

None of this is to say that every protest has been handled perfectly. Where there are specific instances of misconduct or excessive force, they should be investigated. And a discussion about methods and tactics is important for addressing legitimate concerns and ensuring all New Yorkers—including peaceful protesters—feel protected. But dismantling the entire apparatus creates a violence free-for-all. That is a step too far.

The mayor’s decision—to disband SRG rather than improve it—makes New York less safe. You can almost picture the press releases: Officials will condemn the inevitable violence that follows, calling it “random” and “senseless” when it is actually predictable and preventable. As always, it’s the innocent, hardworking New Yorkers who will pay the price.

My first thought when I heard Mamdani’s announcement was that this will hearten antisemitic and pro-Palestinian protestors who intend to hurt Jews or for whom hurting Jews is a likely outcome.  As you should know, anti-Jewish hate crimes are far more frequent than anti-black or anti-Muslim hate crimes. I’ve put the data for NYC below, and you can see that more than 52% of all hate crime incidents in New York City, more than 52% to 57% of them were against Jews: more than all other hate crimes combined. I’ve put in the references below (you can click on the two links), and my question to Grok is in bold.

In the last year, how many anti-Jewish hate crimes were committed in NYC versus anti-Black hate crimes and anti-Muslim hate crimes?
Grok’s answer:

In calendar year 2025 (the most recent full year with complete NYPD data), there were 330 reported anti-Jewish hate crime incidents in New York City, compared with 45 anti-Black and 30 anti-Muslim incidents, out of 576 total hate crime incidents.

These figures come from NYPD data released in early January 2026 and have been consistently reported across multiple outlets citing the same official numbers. Anti-Jewish incidents accounted for about 57% of the total (more than all other categories combined), despite Jewish New Yorkers representing roughly 10% of the city’s population. Overall hate crimes fell about 12% from 657 in 2024, and anti-Jewish incidents were down about 3% from 339 the prior year.

But it’s not just Jews who will suffer, though I’m sure that was on Mamdani’s mind when he announced this. The other groups will, too, especially small store owners who can lose their livelihood, as they did in the recent Paris riots.  What was Mamdani thinking when he made this bonehead decision?  To enact a defunding of the police, I think, as well as to satisfy his DSA supporters, and to give a big middle finger to Jews and those who think that the police are essential, especially in these troubled times.  Those people who voted for Mamdani, especially the Jews, are going to get what they deserve. And Democrats who endorse him will eventually regret their decision.

 

Here are three responses.  First, a direct message that arrived from my friend, U of C neurobiologist Peggy Mason (she is Jewish), right as I was writing this. She had independently read about Mamdani’s announcement and contacted me (we’re both up early, though she’s in British Columbia). Her words are redacted to protect the sensitive, and the quote is with permission.

I’m so disgusted. New Yorkers are going to learn the consequences of their election in a very painful way and I hope those f—–g do gooder Jews who voted for him feel really f——g bad.

Second, a tweet following the video above:

The Babylon Bee had its usual sarcastic take. (Click below to read.)

“We’re spending millions to address a problem that doesn’t exist,” said Mamdani. “New York City has never experienced any sort of terrorism before, leaving this police force with literally nothing to do. This is exactly the kind of government waste that we are wanting to target. New Yorkers want to know that their tax dollars are being spent on actual problems that have plagued the city, such as a lack of city-owned grocery stores selling government cheese.”

Asked whether he might be overlooking a significant event in the city’s history, Mamdani dismissed the suggestion.

“If something like that had happened here, surely someone would have told us to never forget it,” he said. “So either it never happened, or people forgot. Either way, it’s clearly not a big deal to New Yorkers.”

At publishing time, Mamdani had also disbanded the Central Park police unit, citing the fact that nothing bad had ever happened there.

Click “continue reading” to see Grok’s answer to my question about the relative frequency of demonstrations against Israel versus those against Hamas/Palestine.

Continue reading “Mamdani disbands police unit targeting terrorism and violent protests, replaces with unarmed unit using “dialogue” and “de-escalation”” →

Tuesday: Hili dialogue

November 17, 2026 • 6:45 am

Welcome to The Cruelest Day: Tuesday, November 17, 2026, and National Baklava Day, celebrating the world’s finest pastry. Here is a baklava shop I found in Istanbul in 2008, and ONE SERVING for me (I love the stuff). Do not judge me.

It’s also Homemade Bread Day, International Happy Gose Day (Gose is a wheat beer), World Butter Day, and World Peace Day.

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 1 7 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

*The people of Ukraine are going to have a tough winter, as the Russians plan to destroy facilities that lead to the starvation, freezing, and other debilitation of noncombatant Ukrainians (article archived here).

*In a post at It’s Noon in Israel, Amit Segal tells us that Hamas and the UN, not Israel, have blocked attempts to give Gazans better shelter for the approaching winter.

Winter has arrived in the Gaza Strip. With the rain has come a storm of criticism over Israel’s failure to shelter displaced Gazans. As usual, there is a notable omission.

Threats from Hamas forced the UN Development Programme to abandon a plan to install improved shelters for families living in tents, according to a Ramallah-based Palestinian Authority official who spoke to the Arabic-language outlet Jusoor. The official, who was not authorized to speak publicly, said Hamas threatened PA staff working on the project with kneecapping.

In February, UNDP began replacing 300 tents in Gaza City’s Al-Zaytoun neighborhood with 19-square-meter prefabricated units—sealed doors, ventilation windows, solar lighting. In April, Alessandro Mrakic, head of UNDP’s Gaza office, said the units would provide “more dignity, privacy, and protection during the winter.” Around 4,000 were planned.

The problem was who was involved.

The PA’s Ministry of Public Works and Housing ran the surveys and dealt with camp residents. In September, the official said, Hamas summoned its staff and told them to stop. They didn’t. A week later, Hamas summoned them again and made them sign a pledge to stay out of the camps. Violators would be kneecapped.

Hamas saw the project as a threat to its control of the camps. When reached for comment, Gaza-based ministry officials declined to comment. “We don’t want to create more problems,” one said. But according to Palestinian analyst Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, Public Works staff had been coerced into signing pledges not to run humanitarian projects without Hamas approval, under threat of “field justice.”

*The Free Press discusses how Chuck Schumer may not have a lock on being Senate majority leader when the new Congress convenes next year. He has a challenger, and the challenger is much more negative on Israel than is Schumer. I guess that counts as a positive for Van Hollen in the “new” Democratic Party, despite Schumer having presided over a historic Democratic recapture of the Senate.

. . . Schumer is facing an insurgent challenger, Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland senator who aligns with the progressive wing of his party. Since formally announcing his bid to be majority leader, Van Hollen has blasted Schumer for endorsing moderates in Senate primaries earlier this year. He has also threatened to shut down the federal government in order to defund the war in Iran.

Van Hollen may not be likely to win. Unlike the House, the insurgent left is still nascent in the Senate with only a handful of committed members, including old-timer Bernie Sanders, newcomers such as Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Troy Jackson of Maine, and sometime fellow travelers like Connecticut’s Chris Murphy. But the challenge to Schumer shows that Democrats’ rift over Israel wasn’t mere election fodder. It will be the most important factional line within the next congressional majority—and the side most hostile to Israel has the momentum, despite Schumer’s attempts to catch up.

The two candidates for majority leader are chalk and cheese. Schumer comes from the middle class. His father was an exterminator in Brooklyn who saved money to send him to Harvard. Van Hollen, on the other hand, was born in Karachi, Pakistan, where his father was in the foreign service and his mother worked as an intelligence analyst.

The biggest difference between Van Hollen and Schumer is how both approach U.S. policy toward Israel. Van Hollen, in recent years, has distinguished himself as a bitter foe of the Jewish state and its war in Gaza. In 2025, after leading a delegation of lawmakers to Gaza, Van Hollen and Senator Jeff Merkley of Oregon issued a report that accused Israel of ethnic cleansing. This year, Van Hollen voted for a bill to ban the sale of offensive weapons systems to Israel. He also said last week that the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee should refuse to take any money from the largest pro-Israel lobby, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC.

Schumer, for his part, has evolved over the years to cater to the leftward drift of his own party. He has not said whether he supports or opposes getting rid of the filibuster. Schumer has promised to zero out funding for the Iran war and proposed legislation to provide some federal regulation of the AI industry. And while Schumer voted against the bill this year to block the sale of offensive weapons to Israel, the senator from New York has also publicly chastised Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu. In 2024, Schumer gave a floor speech calling on Israelis to hold new elections and labeled Netanyahu one of four “obstacles to peace,” along with extremist Israeli settlers, Hamas, and the leader of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas.

More recently, Schumer was one of the first senators to endorse Abdul El-Sayed after he defeated Rep. Haley Stevens in the party’s Senate primary in August. Schumer endorsed Stevens in that contest. Despite pressure from pro-Israel organizations, Schumer steered $10 million from his own Senate Majority PAC to El-Sayed’s campaign for the general election. When Stevens herself withdrew support for El-Sayed and endorsed his Republican opponent, Schumer said she had committed an act of “despicable betrayal.”

It’s bad enough that Schumer, who is Jewish, endorsed El-Sayed, who I regard as an antisemite, but I suppose he was obliged to endorse all Democratic candidates for Senate who have won theur primaries.(Still, I don’t think that Stevens committed an act of “despicable betrayal” by going with her conscience.) On the other hand, I’d rather have Schumer in charge than “a bitter foe of the Jewish state and its war on Gaza.” I presume that Van Hollen thought that on October 7, 2023, Israel should not have responded to the terrorist attack that killed over 1200 people, right? It baffles me why this kind of anti-Israel behavior is spreading through the Democratic Party.

*Again from the Free Press, which discusses the case of Ilhan Omar. While freely admitting that the investigation was motivated by Trump’s political animus, Jed Rubenfeld, in his article “Will the case against Ilhan Omar hold up?” is more concerned with discussing the merits of the case. Conclusion: it’s far from open and shut, but there’s little new to learn.

. . . it has been widely reported that the Justice Department is investigating two primary allegations: (1) that Omar married her own brother in 2009 to help him obtain immigration papers; and (2) that she was 18, not 17, when she received U.S. citizenship in 2000. (A separate investigation, led by U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro, is looking into alleged financial improprieties.)

It’s plausible that the administration is targeting Omar for political reasons. She’s a founding member of the progressive “Squad” and a harsh critic of Donald Trump. Last month, the president called Omar “a sick,” “very dishonest person” who “hates our country.” After Omar and Rep. Rashida Tlaib (a Palestinian American) protested Trump at this year’s State of the Union address, the president posted on Truth Social that “we should send them back from where they came—as fast as possible.”

On the other hand, this isn’t the first time Omar has faced legal scrutiny. The Justice Department and Department of Homeland Security probed her immigration history when she ran for the Minnesota House in 2016—while Barack Obama was president. That investigation ended without charges when prosecutors determined that any crimes she might have committed were beyond the statute of limitations. But the fact that a Democratic administration probed Omar to begin with suggests that there’s more than raw politics going on here.

. . . Let’s take the allegations one at a time. Could she really have married her brother? Incredibly, she may indeed have done so. In fact, while there’s no proof, I’d have to say that based on currently available evidence, it’s more likely than not. But while this allegation is the most scandalous, it may have the least legal impact.

. . . entering a sham marriage to procure immigration papers for one’s brother is criminal immigration fraud. But the statute of limitations for that crime is five years—a period that passed long ago. Even if Omar was still technically conspiring to commit immigration fraud with Elmi all the way through 2017, when they were formally divorced, the limitations period would still be long over.

This claim could be disproven with a simple DNA test, but for some reason Omar has refused to take one (her brother would have to do it, too). Perhaps the search of her house got the DNA evidence, at least from her. The other allegation, which according to Rubenfeld has more serious consequences for Omar,is that Omar misrepresented her age when as 17 when she became an American citizen, for she could not have gotten citizenship at 18.

If Omar was 18 in 2000, she never legally obtained U.S. citizenship. As an 18-year-old, she would have been required to apply for citizenship on her own, satisfying the then-applicable criteria. She might well have obtained citizenship through that process, but that might-have is legally irrelevant. If her 2000 derivatively obtained citizenship was unlawful, it appears her current status would be an alien, noncitizen lawful permanent resident.

This has potentially profound legal ramifications. No statute of limitations applies to denaturalization proceedings.

Rubenfeld’s conclusion?

I myself find Omar close to unbearable. Her recent campaigning with streamer Hasan (“I hate America”) Piker is an example. But being insufferable is not grounds for deportation, and the bottom line is this: There is a strong chance that she will escape the Justice Department’s investigation unscathed.

The most scandalous allegation—that she married her own brother—may well be true, but the potential legal impact is small. By contrast, the seemingly much more technical allegation—that she was 18 rather than 17 in 2000—packs potentially drastic legal consequences, but the proof required for those consequences may well be unattainable.

I’m still wondering why the judge authorized a search of Omar’s home, and took six hours of scrutiny of the government’s case before signing the warrant. That amount of time is very unusual.  Is there something incriminating that we don’t know? Well, we have two more years to find out—as long as Trump is President. I thought this whole thing was simply a Trumpian political vendetta—until the search warrant was authorized.

*Here’s clickbait in the NYT, at least for a zoologist: ““Birdbrain’ is a misnomer.  Crows can make decisions faster than we can.” The authors of the paper below studied the ability of two carrion crows to decide which way a group of dots were moving by pecking at a “target” dot that indicated direction.  Here’s a photo from the NYT (with credit to one of the paper’s authors) showing the setup: a central group of dots that move, either together or mostly, to the right or left (or up or down), with the birds pecking at the target indicating the “majority” direction. You can see the two targets below, and the birds were trained how to respond beforehand.  They pecked very quickly at the targets, and with very high accuracy.

An excerpt from the NYT:

. . . . birds can make staggeringly quick decisions, besting their human and nonhuman primate counterparts with ease. In new findings published in Science, the crows could process and respond to visual cues at twice the speed as humans and monkeys, quantifying the neural speed of avian decision-making for the first time.

The discovery might be the final blow for the use of “birdbrains” as a pejorative.

“We wouldn’t think of birds making these decisions faster than monkeys, or faster than us ‘awesome’ human beings,” said Mike Colombo, a neuroscientist and comparative psychologist at the University of Otago in New Zealand who was not involved in the research. “But they do. They’re just incredibly fast.”

. . .For the new study, researchers at the University of Tübingen in Germany wanted to better understand how crows make decisions, so they set up an experiment to record their brain activity as the birds performed a visual task. After several weeks of training — and countless mealworm treats — Lemmy and Iggy learned to peck left or right to match the orientation of flashing white dots on a black screen.

During the experiment, the dots would randomly orient facing left or right. Sometimes a majority of the dots would align in one direction, making the task easy. Other times, only a small percentage would change, making it difficult. The crows’ objective was to peck the screen to match the orientation of the dots; at the same time, their neural activity was recorded by electrodes.

It ain’t so easy: if you can access the original article, have a look at two of the moving groups of dots the birds had to deal with.

. . .For the new study, researchers at the University of Tübingen in Germany wanted to better understand how crows make decisions, so they set up an experiment to record their brain activity as the birds performed a visual task. After several weeks of training — and countless mealworm treats — Lemmy and Iggy learned to peck left or right to match the orientation of flashing white dots on a black screen.

During the experiment, the dots would randomly orient facing left or right. Sometimes a majority of the dots would align in one direction, making the task easy. Other times, only a small percentage would change, making it difficult. The crows’ objective was to peck the screen to match the orientation of the dots; at the same time, their neural activity was recorded by electrodes.

. . . The crows were allowed three seconds to make their decisions, but the results revealed they needed less than one. They reliably pecked their answers in about 235 milliseconds, which is twice as fast as rhesus monkeys or humans when performing similar experiments. Moreover, they pecked their decisions at breakneck speeds without compromising accuracy. “This was a result that we didn’t anticipate,” Dr. Nieder said.

Of course this doesn’t mean that birds are “smart” in the “intelligence” sense, as implied in the title saying “birdbrains” is a “misnomer”.  Lots of animals can do stuff faster or better than we can, and the discriminatory ability of crows may reflect their evolutionary history more than smarts. The article does mention this at the end:

The Tübingen team suspects the ability to make such quick decisions might have evolved in response to the risky world of flight, where the difference between quickly or slowly reacting to something in the field of vision could be the difference between a smooth flight and crashing, or missing out on food.

Remember that some birds can fly at high speed through dense forest, avoiding all the trees. That would reflect a similar kind of ability.

You can read the original paper by clicking below.

There’s also a Perspective in Science that you can read by clicking below:

The authors of the paper and Perspective attribute the speed of the crows to the arrangement of the neurons in their brain, but you can read about that here.

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, but Andrzej has posted a vintage Hili Dialogue:

Hili: Did Rousseau have a cat?
Andrzej: I don’t know, why do you ask?
Hili: I’m wondering where he got the idea of the noble savage from.

In Polish:

Hili: Czy Rousseau miał kota?
Ja: Nie wiem, dlaczego pytasz?
Hili: Zastanawiam się, skąd mu się wzięła koncepcja szlachetnego dzikusa.

*******************

From Cats, Coffee & Chaos: CATZILLA!

From Meow Incorporated:

From Funny and Strange Signs:

 

Curious, the timing of this gender transition!  Fortunately, the woman did survive, and the man who identified as a woman got ten years (that would be a light sentence in the U.S. You can read about it in The Daily Fail.

From Malcolm , a cat ladder:

From the Number Ten Cat. The translation of the Arabic in Hitchens post is “Let me introduce you to the cat who has an official position at the British ambassador’s residence. 🐈#غاريالقطالدبلوماسي.”  Hitchen is the British Ambassador to Saudi Arabia, and he introduces us to the new cat there: Gary!

One I found. Discuss.

Two from my feed. First, the guy who played Doron, the star of “Fauda”, and you must watch that complete series:

Agile cats:

One I reposted frm The Auschwitz Memorial:

This Czech Jewish boy was gassed as soon as he arrived in Auschwitz. He was 14 years old.

— Jerry Coyne (@evolutionistrue.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T11:33:33.857Z

And one from Doctor Cobb: Orca sighting with a link:

Rare Orca Sighting. Read the full story here: buff.ly/GdkW8BW Video by MaxThis is an encounter from 2026#WhaleTales #orca

— Whale Tales (@whaletalesorg.bsky.social) 2026-11-05T21:35:32.953Z

Readers’ wildlife photos

November 16, 2026 • 8:30 am

We have more fungus among us, courtesy of reader Jan Malik, who has sent another batch of mushroom photos from the Catskills, Adirondacks, and the White Mountains (his first post about mushrooms is here).  Jan’s captions and IDs are indented below, and you can enlarge the photos by clicking on them. I like the fact that Jan mentions the edibility of these mushrooms.

While the previous batch of mushrooms included various orders, presenting a selection of easy-to-recognize edible mushrooms (and their toxic lookalikes), in this batch we have only mycorrhizal mushrooms from the Boletaceae and Russulaceae families. This is a relatively safe group of mushrooms for anyone to start their mushroom hunting, as there are no deadly poisonous species in it. A few are fairly toxic, and others warn you with their bitter taste.

Boletes are characterized by a fleshy stem and a symmetrical cap with pores on the underside. In my travels through the US Northeast woodlands, I have not yet found the most sought-after bolete—the porcini—but here are some others. Take the species ID with a grain of salt; many boletes look alike, and it’s difficult to make an accurate determination in the field without a microscope, vials of chemicals, and the time to make a spore print.

The scaber stalks are members of the Leccinum genus; this one is possibly Leccinum vulpinum. They are symbionts with spruces or pines—receiving sugar from the plant and giving back nitrogen, phosphorus, and various mineral salts. I remember they stain your hands black when sliced for cooking, which for me used to be a one-pot meal, simmered in sour cream with potatoes, onions, and carrots. Recently I learned they are not recommended since they cause gastrointestinal upset in some people, but I never had any problems:

The Painted Bolete (Suillus spraguei) grows in obligate symbiosis with the Eastern white pine in moist places like the edges of boreal bogs and lakes. It is a good edible, but like other “slippery jack” boletes in the Suillus genus, it oozes some slime when cooked. Some don’t like it, but for me, it is quite like an okra dish. Good for a mushroom and beans stew:

This is likely the Red-mouth Bolete (Neoboletus subvelutipes). They kindly alert a possible collector of their toxicity by their red pore surface and the fact that, when cut, they immediately stain blue. In the boreal forest, it grows in mycorrhizal partnership with hemlock, oak, or beech:

Probably the Bitter Bolete (Tylopilus felleus), a general tree symbiont that prefers conifers but will grow in broadleaf forests, too. It looks succulent and appetizing but is extremely bitter. One cap mixed with other mushrooms will ruin a whole meal. The bitterness must have evolved in an otherwise harmless bolete as a defense against vertebrates, although it may not protect them against insect larvae:

Possibly the Bay Bolete (Imleria badia). It grows in symbiosis with conifer trees. If I were sure of the correct ID, I’d go ahead and collect it—it is a choice edible. If I wasn’t quite sure, but knowing that it is not deadly poisonous (bolete: check; pores not red: check; doesn’t stain blue when cut: check; not bitter: check), I’d cook and eat just a small part of a cap and wait for results. That’s how the edibility of each mushroom was established by our ancestors thousands of years ago. Let’s honor all those unknown, fallen heroes of culinary art with a minute of silence now:

I suspect this is Butyriboletus brunneus. The giveaways are a sturdy, finely reticulated stipe that is red at the base and a light brown cap. It grows in mycorrhizal symbiosis with oaks and other deciduous trees. It is possibly edible, but collecting it would be going a little too deep into the “Russian roulette” zone for me:

This could be a member of the porcini complex, the Chippewa bolete (Boletus chippewaensis). It is very likely edible, even though it looks a bit different from a classical porcini—the stipe is more slender rather than bulbous and its reticulation is more subtle, but the cap is brown-reddish like that of a proper porcini. The final test would be to make a spore print and possibly look at the spores under a microscope. If confirmed, it can be thinly sliced and sautéed in butter with herbs for an aromatic meal; it is also excellent dried and added to soups or mushroom pierogies with a porcini and fried onion filling:

Another bitter bolete, possibly Tylopilus rubrobrunneus, judging by traces of pink and violet. Mushroom identification is complicated by the variable appearance of a toadstool when young and old, the type of soil it grows in, parasitic fungal infections, whether it is wet or dry etc.:

Now onward to Russulas, which together with the milk caps form the family Russulaceae. These are gilled mushrooms, which raises the bar considerably compared to boletes—many toxic and deadly mushrooms have gills too. Russulas’ caps can be all hues of red, brown, yellow, burgundy or green, and there are many species. They are all fragile and their gills break off easily; their stipes are not fibrous, usually empty and they lack a veil. It is really difficult to make an exact species determination without a microscope and a lot of experience. But, if it is indeed a Russula, it is not deadly, and the toxic ones, in my experience, can be ruled out by the acrid taste of the raw flesh (that burning taste usually disappears after cooking, but the toxicity does not). Also in my experience, most of the toxic ones are bright red or yellow, while dull red, green, or wine colors are good for a mushroom stew or a broth base. These are all folklore heuristics (“other ways of knowing””), so one has to be really careful when collecting them for the table.

This one, for example, could be the Sickener (Russula emetica). Obviously, it is not good for consumption.

Possibly the Yellow swamp russula (Russula claroflava). I never collected yellow russulas, but they can be edible:

Possibly the Copper brittlegill (Russula decolorans); likely edible:

Possibly the Grass green russula (Russula aeruginea). It is a Schrödinger’s mushroom: edible and toxic at the same time, until you eat it to make sure:

The last picture proves that Russulas are indeed harvested as food. I found this young mushroom, put aside for later by a squirrel or chipmunk, in a trailless Catskills forest:

 

Monday: Hili dialogue

November 16, 2026 • 6:45 am

We made it through a chilly weekend in Chicago, and now it’s the “work week”: today is Monday, November 16, 2026, and it’s National Fast Food Day. Here’s a guy constructing my burger at the Five Guys place in Hyde Park. I’ve stopped going there as the burgers are overpriced, but they do give you huge quantities of fries. The food is good, but at “$20-30 per meal”, it’s too rich for my blood.”

It’s also National Button Day and International Day for Tolerance.  Buttons are old but were first used as ornaments rather than to secure clothes:

Ian McNeil (1990) holds that “the button was originally used more as an ornament than as a fastening, the earliest known being found at Mohenjo-daro in the Indus Valley. It is made of a curved shell and is about 5000 years old.”

Readers are welcome to mark notable events, births, or deaths on this day by consulting the November 16 Wikipedia page.

Da Nooz:

*About a week ago Andrew Sullivan suggested that Trump resign from the Presidency. In his most recent column, “Tear. It. Down.“, he suggests that the new White House ballroom, which we know is HUGE, should be demolished.  As I don’t subscribe, I’m not sure if there’s anything more than what you can see at the link, but here’s an excerpt of what you can see:

This deference of public architecture to democratic deliberation is not new. When L’Enfant first presented his idea for a new presidential palace to George Washington, everyone saw it as an auspicious moment. A brand new republic, with a blank page to draw on, and an executive branch to be defined. And the planned palace was indeed impressive: four times the size of the current White House.

And that was the problem. Washington was horrified by the scale of the blueprints. It was more redolent of a monarch’s estate than a president’s house. A contest was then held for a new design, and a far more modest, simple house was constructed — a deliberate rejection of monarchism — with the cornerstone laid in 1792. The most radical change since then was the Truman Balcony, which occasioned a huge fuss, but eventually became accepted.

I grew up abroad in a constitutional monarchy with all its bells and whistles, and found the American president’s abode a near-perfect expression of late 18th-century republican aspirations. Understated, elegant, classical: the power comes precisely from its restraint. And as a Washingtonian, there are few greater pleasures than taking the day to ride a bike around the mall, and take in the majesty and simplicity of the formal architecture.

So I feel real grief right now — yes, grief — as this vile man takes a sledgehammer to this inheritance, as he has to so many parts of our liberal democracy:

This is the photo Sullivan uses; it is uncredited but horrifying.

Look at it: hulking, dominating, out of scale, transforming the entire site, turning the White House into an afterthought. It’s a perfect symbol of what Trump has done to our democracy. He asked no one’s permission, stacked every commission with cronies and hacks, demolished the East Wing with almost no notice, and financed the boondoggle with bribes from major corporate machers, including, yes, Jensen Huang.

The new Trump House is about 90,000 sq ft, compared to the 55,000 of the former White House itself. The monstrousness is not fully clear yet — but as it takes shape some more, and the sheer scale of it sinks in, it will become apparent what this is really about: stamping Trump’s brand on our democracy forever. It might as well have a giant, gold TRUMP banner on it. It’s a monument to autocracy, oligarchy, and corruption.

That’s why I’m not just being rhetorical in arguing that it must be stopped or, if not stopped, torn down as soon as we can. It’s not just the aesthetic offense. It’s that its survival will be a permanent insinuation of Trumpism into our national character and identity. We can expel this authoritarian toxin by elections, as we just did. But we cannot when a deranged autocrat violates a sacred common inheritance to perpetuate his ego long after his death. In bricks and mortar. An eternal monument to autocracy, lawlessness, and corruption.

Tear. It. Down.

Yes, LOOK AT THAT THING!  Sullivan goes on to say that he wants it down not just because it’s an “aesthetic offense,” which it is, but because it will stamp “Trump” on America’s House forever: it will be a monument to his autocracy and egotism. And he’s right. Once it’s done, though, will it be possible to tear down?

*If you’re wondering whether the ground stop the other day will disrupt any flight plans you have for Thanksgiving, the NYT says “no”, and gives more details about that massive interruption of travel. (Update: there are still flight delays this morning: Monday.)

Effects of a nationwide ground stop on air travel Friday evening, which stranded thousands of passengers and caused widespread delays, have rippled through the weekend, as airlines canceled thousands of flights and airports struggled to recover.

The number of flights facing disruption on Sunday was lower than the day before, according to FlightAware, a flight tracking service, but tens of thousands of passengers still faced snarls. FlightAware said that more than 4,000 flights scheduled for Sunday had been either delayed or canceled as of 10:30 a.m. Eastern. More than 15,000 were delayed or canceled on Saturday.

The air traffic control system, which faced a faulty upgrade that caused communications failures leading to the ground stop, is expected to be back to normal by Sunday night, said Bryan Bedford, who leads the Federal Aviation Administration. Flight schedules could take several days to return to normal.

Federal officials are still trying to determine who is at fault and have called for congressional funding to prevent similar failures. There is no evidence that the problem was caused by a cyberattack, officials have said.

L3Harris, a contractor managing the F.A.A.’s telecoms network, made a standard upgrade at a remote air traffic location, federal officials said Saturday. L3Harris was conducting a routine task — replacing copper wire with more modern fiber optic cable — that was expected to pose no significant disruption to air traffic, said Sean Duffy, the transportation secretary.

But the switch from copper to fiber overwhelmed the system with levels of data it could not handle, prompting widespread communications failures across air traffic facilities that manage the national air space. Alarmed at the scope of the problems, officials issued a rare nationwide ground stop for hours.

No worries, at least for future travel and barring hackers or further problems with fiber optics.

*I usually skip articles about mortality or ageing (too painful!), but the one in the NYT by Roger Rosenblatt, “Thoughts near the end of a life” (he’s 86 or so, apparently not dying), seemed to me better than most. (Article is archived here.under the title, “Late in life, here’s what I know,)

Have I made a ripple with my life? The question every old person asks. Family, yes. Wife, children, grandchildren. Friends, yes. Work? As a writer, who knows? You send things out to an unseen public, like paper boats on water. Do you change a mind, a heart? Abdul El-Sayed, the senator-elect from Michigan, says that his religion teaches that saving one life is like saving all of humanity. The same thought is in the Talmud. That’s the writer’s creed as well.

That’s a Jewish saying that El-Sayed stole; it appears in the Sanhedrin three centures before Muhammad lived and should be credited to that, not El-Sayed, who is antisemitic anyway. But I digress.  Changing the minds of other mortals seems to me a poor way to judge a life unless you affect the future of humanity. I don’t worry too much about this, nor about my scientific legacy, which will be superceded by the work of other scientists (some of them in my department!). I’m satisfied knowing that I changed the course of science by getting more people to study speciation, and I don’t need to have made a contribution like discovering the structure of DNA.

More digression: the Sanhedrin story is interpreted at the link this way:

Ignoring the math, the Talmud rules: Even if all of them will be killed, they must not hand over a single soul.

Why? Because each human life contains at its core the very essence of G‑d. As G‑d is infinite, so the value of a human life.

I’m an atheist, so if that statement has any traction to me, it means something different. And it does: to me it means that the saving any life, human or animal, saves the world entire for that creature, who will have a life that it wouldn’t have had without intervention. But on to Rosenblatt:

There is a special kind of usefulness in the extension of empathy toward others, especially those who may feel deserted and alone. Every week or so, I write to one or another friend who recently lost a partner. The usefulness comes from making others feel worthy of your time and attention. In the cold isolations of modern life, to help them feel love or something akin to it.

It was said of Fyodor Dostoyevsky that he had active empathy. In older age one learns the value of that gift, which takes a lifetime to appreciate and apply. Maybe that is how one assesses progress in a life. To grow from self-interest to active empathy, which gives a certain peace

I agree with that, but of course if you want to have the most useful life, according to Rosenblatt, you should be a doctor in a country lacking doctors, for you’d be saving lives that would otherwise be lost.  Few of us can be such humanitarians, and perhaps I sound selfish in saying that I envision asking the question on my deathbed and being satisfied if I saw a sufficient amount of this diverse world, both in terms of people, culture, natural history, and geography, and that I didn’t leave the world a worse place than it would have been without me.

This is really the subject for an entire post, so think about it. It’s enough for Rosenblatt that he’s started me thinking about the issue. But when I’m dead I will be gone, so I care nothing about my intellectual legacy. I won’t be around to see it.

*In an article in The Chronicle of Higher Education Review called “My students can’t read,” educator Tyler Jagt, whose present school is isn’t identified, adds to the chorus of professors complaining about functional illiteracy.

Six weeks into the term, I assigned my rhetoric and writing students a 20-page article. It was the same length I had assigned for five years and the same length I had read without complaint as an undergraduate a decade ago. Not one student finished it.

When I asked why, a student answered honestly: It was too long, and she kept losing track of what the paper was about. This was not a remedial class: These were students who had cleared the admissions process and written essays good enough to get them here. Yet a routine academic reading assignment had defeated them.

Every generation of professors has complained that their students cannot read. The lament is usually overblown, but data have caught up to anecdote, and what I am seeing in my classroom is no longer a hunch. There is a measurable, generational collapse in sustained reading and writing, and the academy is responding to it with improvisation and exhaustion rather than the structural overhaul it requires.

. . .The Chronicle of Higher Education’s 2024 investigation found the same pattern across institutions as different as the Stevens Institute of Technology and Wellesley College, where the average SAT exceeds 1400. Nicholaus Gutierrez, an assistant professor at Wellesley, told The Chronicle that the baseline for what students consider a reasonable amount of work has dropped so noticeably that he has cut his readings accordingly; a 750-word essay now strikes many students as long. At Stevens, the science and technology studies associate professor Theresa MacPhail described following the mantra of “meet your students where they are” for so long that she has begun to feel “like a cruise director organizing games of shuffleboard.”

Worse, the national data tell the same story in colder language. On the 2011 National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) writing assessment, which is the most recent comprehensive writing benchmark, only 24 percent of 12th graders reached the Proficient level, and just 3 percent reached Advanced; another 21 percent scored below Basic. The reading side of the ledger is worse, and getting worse fast: The 2024 NAEP results released in September 2025 show 12th-grade reading scores at the lowest level recorded since the assessment began in 1992.

One reason is obvious: the use of smartphones, which themselves impede comprehension. The spread of AI is another reason Jagt gives is this practice, which is growing:

. . . . the practice of pulling “evidence” from disconnected short passages, the same format used on the standardized tests that increasingly determine school funding.

I’ll add that I have some anecdotal experience that jibes with this. When I started teaching Introductory Evolution at the University of Maryland, I asked the students to read On the Origin of Species by Darwin. They did it, though they grumbled. Several decades later at Chicago, when I had less time (half a quarter instead of a semester, I asked them to read instead the abridged Norton edition of The Origin—120 pages instead of the original’s 500. It didn’t fly, and I abandoned that assignment.

How do you fix it? Jagt says he doesn’t have the answer, and even banning smartphones and AI in class won’t work, as they are widely used outside of class. He does have questions like these, though:

If higher education is going to respond to the reading crisis as a structural problem rather than a private burden carried by composition instructors and adjuncts, it has to stop avoiding the following questions: If a majority of incoming students cannot read at a level the curriculum requires, are we admitting students we cannot serve, or offering a curriculum we cannot provide?

Why are first-year writing and reading-intensive general-education courses still the most adjunctified, lowest-paid, highest-load corner of the university, at the precise moment when their work has become the most important work the institution does? What is the responsible institutional response for AI usage: Is it a syllabus statement, or a sequencing principle that requires students to demonstrate the cognitive work themselves before AI assistance is permitted?

All of us realize that fixing this—if it’s indeed fixable at all—will be an onerous task. I’m afraid that colleges have neither the will nor the resources to do this in today’s device-rich environment.

*SpaceX launched another Starship rocket, and the amazing thing is that for the first time the upper stage was caught by a giant pair of pincers (“chopsticks”) as it returned to earth. The booster was also supposed to be caught and reused but had to be aborted and exploded because it appeared to not be on a “catch” trajectory. But the catching of the capsule, shown in the video below, is fantastic, especially because it made 14 complete orbits of the Earth in 22 hours.  And the ship launched a bunch of satellites:  A report from Space.com (h/t Bat):

SpaceX caught the upper stage of its Starship megarocket for the first time ever today (Nov. 14), a landmark achievement that could unlock the giant vehicle’s immense potential.

Starship launched on its 15th test flight on Friday evening (Nov. 13), rising into the sky from SpaceX’s Starbase site in South Texas. The mission plan called for bringing both of the vehicle’s stages back to Starbase and catching them with the launch tower’s “chopstick” arms — an unprecedented total recovery of an orbital rocket.

That didn’t happen; Starship’s Super Heavy booster diverted to a Gulf of Mexico splashdown on Friday after experiencing a low-fuel alarm. But Ship succeeded in its attempt, notching a huge milestone for SpaceX and its dream of full rocket reuse.

“That was the missing link,” SpaceX’s Dan Huot said during the company’s landing webcast today, his voice thick with emotion. “That was the holy grail of spaceflight, plummeting through fire to be snatched out of the air by steel. We caught a Starship, and now everything changes.”

. . .Many SpaceX employees went outside to watch the vehicle, known as Ship 42, descend through the clouds toward its Starbase launch tower, which the company calls “Mechazilla.”

And they got quite a show: Ship 42 nestled gently into Mechazilla’s waiting arms, while “Baby Come Back” played over SpaceX’s landing webcast.

“This is so incredible to see,” SpaceX’s Jessie Anderson said during the livestream. “One of the most incredible and historic engineering feats of all time has just happened right in front of our eyes.”

Why was this such a big deal? SpaceX had already caught Super Heavy — on three previous Starship test flights, in fact. But it had never tried before with Ship. The upper stage is a tougher target, for it flies higher, farther and faster than the booster. Indeed, on Flight 15, Ship 42 came all the way back down from orbit.

. . .While the double-catch attempt, and the chopsticks success with Ship, were Flight 15’s main headlines, the mission had other objectives as well. One was getting Ship to orbit, which had happened on just one previous Starship launch — Flight 14, which lifted off on Sept. 28.

Ship deployed 26 of SpaceX’s next-gen Starlink V3 broadband satellites in low Earth orbit (LEO) on Flight 14, and it did so again on Flight 15. These 52 spacecraft are the first members of a constellation that will eventually consist of 100,000 satellites, if all goes according to SpaceX’s plan.

Here’s an 11½-minute video explaining everything. The capsule “catch” is at 9:30. It truly is a fantastic achievement.

Meanwhile in Dobrzyn, Hili rests beneath a pear tree, but Andrzej resurrected an old Hili dialogue:

Hili: When did cats domesticate humans?
Andrzej: According to archaeologists, about nine and a half thousand years ago.
Hili: That’s only a theory. The beginnings of civilization are certainly older.

In Polish:

Hili: Kiedy koty udomowiły ludzi?
Ja: Zdaniem archeologów około dziewięć i pół tysiąca lat temu.
Hili: To tylko teoria, początki cywilizacji z pewnością są starsze.

*******************

From Divy:

From Terrible Maps.  Guess what all these countries have in common.  (First answer gets warm congratulations in the comments.)

From Bad Spelling or Grammar on Signs and Notices:

Masih is still pretty quiet. This is from Simon, who was stuck in Memphis by the ground stoppage:

The FAA is now the Cybertruck of aviation.

— Nancy Levine Stearns (@nancylevinestearns.bsky.social) 2026-11-13T22:34:30.829Z

I found this tweet in a story in The College Fix:

Talia vs. a Muslim:

From Malcolm; a nice man feeds the birds:

Two from my feed. First, a Canada Goose rescue:

Antisemitism in the Hunter College Student Government:

One I reposted from The Auschwitz Memorial:

And one from Dr. Cobb. Look at these adorable Pallas Cat kittens!

Tibetan nature photographer Gaihe Badeng (改合巴登) captured this Aug 2025 video in Zhidoi County, Yushu Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture.This family of manuls (Pallas' cat, Otocolobus manul) is a typical size: 3-4 kittens + mom.I'm going to need a ticket to Tibet & an extra-large backpack, please. 🐈🎒

— c0nc0rdance (@c0nc0rdance.bsky.social) 2026-11-14T20:12:27.263Z

The best “rom-coms”

November 15, 2026 • 10:45 am

Romantic comedies, or “rom-coms”, are making their return, or so I’ve noticed. Grok agrees, citing the recent movies “Anyone But You,” “The Idea of You,” “Finding Emily,” and “The Invite” (I’ve seen the last one, which is well worth watching and is more serious than the two movies discussed below.)

I’m not drawn to this genre in particular, but there are times when you need a feel-good movie with a happy ending (yes, a happy ending is a requisite for a good rom-com). After watching “The Invite” (it has a sort-of-happy ending), I thought back about the rom-coms I’ve watched, and two of them came to mind.

The first is the 1999 movie “Notting Hill,” which I love because it has a great plot, superb casting and acting, a happy ending, a lot of twists and turns, and of course features my heartthrob Julia Roberts. (Her best performance is not in a rom-com but in the 2000 film “Erin Brockovich“, for which she won a well-deserved Oscar for Best Actress. ) Hugh Grant is also great, although some critics say he’s just playing himself (I disagree).

“Notting Hill”‘s most famous scene is below when, after ups and downs, Julia Roberts, playing a rich, famous actress named Anna Scott (basically herself) gets involved with Hugh Grant, a Brit who owns a bookstore in London. She realizes that she loves him, and comes to his bookshop to try to keep the relationship alive by asking for another chance. The clip below shows that scene and its setting, featuring Roberts’s famous line, “I’m also just a girl, standing in front of a boy, asking him to love her”.  She loses it during the last five words: terrific acting.  Grant thinks that he’s not up to have his heart broken again, which he thinks would be inevitable with two people having such different lives. And so she departs.

Afterwards, Grant asks his extended family what to do about her, and at first they all agree the relationship is a no-go. Then Grant’s disheveled Welsh roommate hears what she told him and calls Grant “a daft prick” for not continuing the romance. That leads to the happy ending (not shown).

The other is “When Harry Met Sally” (1989) starring Meg Ryan and Billy Crystal.  I’ll show two scenes about the differences between men and women.  In the first, below, Harry (Crystal) explains to an unbelieving Sally why men and women can’t be friends. (They are driving, by the way, from the University of Chicago to New York.) The terrific screenplay was by Nora Ephron, and the director was Rob “Meathead” Reiner):

But of course the most famous scene in that movie is the “fake orgasm” segment filmed in Katz’s Deli in New York. (There’s still a sign over the table where they sat, and people vie to sit there too.). This is a classic scene of movies in any genre. The topper, the line “I’ll have what she’s having,” was not written by Ephron but suggested by Crystal in a read-through and delivered here by Rob Reiner’s mother Estelle.

Oh, hell, I’ll throw in the last scene, too: the happy ending on New Year’s Eve. Nora Ephron was a terrific screenwriter.

There are two other great rom-coms that come to mind: “Sleepless in Seattle” (1993, directed by Nora Ephron and starring Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan) and “You’ve Got Mail” (1998; also starring Hanks and Ryan, with a screenplay Nora Ephron).  I can’t be arsed to put up iconic scenes, mainly because I can’t think of any, but I did like those movies. However, “Notting Hill” and “When Harry Met Sally” top my list of best recent movies in this genre (I’m not considering ones that came out before my time.)

I’m probably forgetting some films, and here is where readers should chime in. Feel free to disagree with my choices or suggest ones you think are better.

Bill Maher plumps for leftist centrism

November 15, 2026 • 9:30 am

Bill Maher’s latest “Real Time” monologue plumps for a centric position between Peak Woke and Republican “full asshole”.  He goes after Trump’s Cabinet, including Kristi Noem and Pete Hegseth, and also has a few choice words about Musk and Ramaswamy—all, he says, “a team of dicks.”

But he also makes fun of  patronizing “lawn sign” Democrats, which, he says, was tiresome to Americans (you know the lawn sign, and yes, it was a tiresome example of virtue signaling).  Also in his sights are land acknowledgements, acceptance of shoplifting, and denigration of standardized tests.

Maher is a classical liberal, so he’s not advocating, I think, for absolute centrism, but more centrism on the left than many people have.

The people on the panel (not shown this week) were attorney and journalist Aaron Parnas and Politico‘s Dasha Burns.

In case you’ve been in Mongolia and haven’t seen the Virtue Lawn Signs, here’s one from Signs of Justice. Every time I see one of these (yes, they’re still around), I have a moment of dyspepsia.

. . . and just for grins, here’s a Jewish Virtue lawn sign that I found on Facebook (h/t Melissa Steinberg Brodsky). Believe me, if you put one of these up it would be removed in a day, and you’d be demonized.

Readers’ wildlife photos

November 15, 2026 • 8:15 am

Thank Ceiling Cat that readers are sending in photos again. I actually have one batch in reserve!

Today’s photos come from UC Davis ecologist Susan Harrison, highlighting the Birds of Fall. Don’t miss the lovely Wood Ducks at the end. Susan’s captions and IDs are indented, and you can enlarge the photos by clicking on them.

Fall (bird) colors

As the season has gone rapidly from golden to gray in Ashland, Oregon, my most exciting bird experience was the flock of Gray-crowned Rosy-finches (Leucosticte tephrocotis) gracing the summit of Mt. Ashland (7,500’).   These remarkable little birds live in alpine zones, where in spring and summer they hunt insects trapped in snowfields. As winter approaches they move down in search of seeds and fruits, while still sticking to cold and open environments. Mt. Ashland with its tiny expanse of near-alpine vegetation is an occasional stopover for them.

Seeing 30+ of them at “Mt. A” was already a thrill, but even more significantly to local birders, this flock was a mix of two geographic forms (subspecies, to some): “Brown-cheeked,” found in the interior western US, and “Hepburn’s” with its all-gray face, which is more coastal and northerly.   These birds are evidently not fussy about the migratory company they keep.

Two Brown-cheeked (first two) and two Hepburn’s Gray-crowned (last two) Rosy-finches:

Morning view of Mt. Shasta, seen while searching for Rosy-finches:

The second best recent sighting I had was of Varied Thrushes (Ixorius naevius) eating the last few pears on our neighbor’s trees.   These lovely birds always make me think of an American Robin with an upgraded trim package.  Unusual numbers of forest seed- and fruit-eating birds have been on the move this fall, looking for winter resources, and Varied Thrushes may be part of this “irruption”.

Varied Thrush:

Varied Thrushes, converted from a not-sharp-enough photo to an Impressionist work by ChatGPT:

During my early morning Varied Thrush – pear tree stakeout, many other birds stopped by.

Hermit Thrush (Catharus guttatus):

California Scrub Jay (Aphelocoma californica):

Ruby-crowned Kinglet (Corthylio calendula):

Spotted Towhee (Pipilio maculatus):

At this time of year, maple-surrounded ponds with Wood Ducks (Aix sponsa) are the go-to places for saturated colors.

Wood Ducks in Lithia Park: